Ribbing players is part of the game - but the "creepy" factor, I think, is on a sliding scale with age.
- If a student was digging into players' histories to find buttons to push, I say fair game.
- If a young alum (which I'd still consider kyk at 27) is doing it, also fairly inbounds within reason (and nothing he said seems to be out of bounds to me - it's all twitter/HS background stuff)
- If a middle aged person (35-50) is doing it, that verges on creepy.
- If an older head (50+) is doing this, it's definitely creepy.
I do feel that some things are definitely "out of bounds", though, for three reasons, imo:
1. Going after family tragedy of any kind. Sister has cancer, mom recently died, etc.... that's not cool, and goes to the "bigger than the game" concept in my mind. Maybe it's just me.
2. Racist jeers/chants
3. Stuff that would make the school look bad. All the one-on-one jawing is invisible to the viewership at home - have at it as long as you don't get caught on tape. Older fans flipping the bird to players is too risky, to me - too easy to get caught on camera, and it become a negative anti-RU story. Chanting "F Penn State" is borderline - but it's rivalry hatred, and that gets some special dispensation. Chanting "F U Navy" crosses this line. Anything that a starved-for-controversy reporter could grab and turn into a story, really.