ADVERTISEMENT

We should fire Pike after this year, however reality is he’ll get fired in March 2024

Status
Not open for further replies.
Any objective and sane-minded individual would look at the recruiting and effort prior to the four game win streak and come to the same exact conclusions.

I’m thrilled they’re playing this well lately and love RU with a passion. But that doesn’t change the fact the effort for 70% of the season was piss poor, recruiting has been a disaster, and next season is terrifying.

Also, our work to get into the tournament this year isn’t done. I’d pump the brakes on the calling people out and celebrating. Let’s see this team finish. If they do, I’ll be as happy as anybody on this board.
It’s about degree. I was concerned both with the losing streak and recruiting. Still am regarding recruiting. I wasn’t calling for Pike’s head.
 
Any objective and sane-minded individual would look at the recruiting and effort prior to the four game win streak and come to the same exact conclusions.

I’m thrilled they’re playing this well lately and love RU with a passion. But that doesn’t change the fact the effort for 70% of the season was piss poor, recruiting has been a disaster, and next season is terrifying.

Also, our work to get into the tournament this year isn’t done. I’d pump the brakes on the calling people out and celebrating. Let’s see this team finish. If they do, I’ll be as happy as anybody on this board.

I love people who sit on their fat asses while posting on a message board criticizing the "effort" of college athletes who likely are in classes, weight rooms, film room almost every waking hour of every day.

So when RU was losing earlier in the season your sane minded conclusion was to fire Pike? Because thats what you're agreeing t o in this thread topic.

Ps...tell us, which recruits you think suck because you're obviously very comfortable at denigrating RU college athletes.
 
A more relevant question is actually should Mike Boynton be fired at 5-8 in conference 12-13 overall
Shiit, I hope so. That would mean Boyton would be available when kike storms Holloway’s office and gets Pike fired. 😂

PS - Kike I usually roll my eyes before reading your needy and simplistic look at me posts, but lately I’ve been wondering about your family tree… did you have an ancestor insisting D-Day in Normandy was just a diversion? How about a relative that believed the Japanese attacking Pearl Harbor would turn out well? Or someone in the recording business that turned down the Beatles?
 
Its not secret that im not the biggest pike fan as the head coach of a big ten program. He is a GREAT man but a very subpar basketball coach.

1) he doesnt recruit well enough for what this job requires
2) hes stuck in the 80’s with his coaching philosophy
3) he doesnt run an offense

the reason we should fire him after this season is because he refuses to adjust his mindset. Hes too afraid of hurting feelings of players rather than putting winning first. If you think this season is bad whats gonna happen next year when we lose our one player capable of scoring (ron)? Hes shown a reluctancy to really go hard at the transfer portal. Yes hes plugged a hole here and there but hes also turned down guys like jahvon quinerly and luther muhammad who wanted to come home! Think about that!

so what’ll now happen. This year we go 3-17 in big ten play and everyone is disappointed but says, “but guys he got us to the tourney and we hadnt been in 3 decades, give him some leash”. Thats just the loser mindset of this fan base because we have buried the bar of what we should expect here. Next year we follow it up with another awful season and now the noise is palpable but we punt the decision one more year. 2023-2024 season is the 3rd straight bad year and we have no choice but to make a coaching change and now the 2024 season starts with a new coach rebuilding taking a few years to get us back to the tourney where we should expect to be every year.

we could start the proper rebuild with a new coach next season but we all know it wont happen for both financial reasons and because of how low the bar is here. But this is inevitable, everyone sees whats coming but we’ll put it off and settle for having a bad team for more years than we need to. I’ll be sure to bump this in march 2024.

One name: Mike Boynton
Could you be more wrong? Everything you predict comes up completely wrong. Maybe you need to stfu and let people who know about sports take over. Is Oregon offense going to be run through Young in NIT?
 
Last edited:
Its not secret that im not the biggest pike fan as the head coach of a big ten program. He is a GREAT man but a very subpar basketball coach.

1) he doesnt recruit well enough for what this job requires
2) hes stuck in the 80’s with his coaching philosophy
3) he doesnt run an offense

the reason we should fire him after this season is because he refuses to adjust his mindset. Hes too afraid of hurting feelings of players rather than putting winning first. If you think this season is bad whats gonna happen next year when we lose our one player capable of scoring (ron)? Hes shown a reluctancy to really go hard at the transfer portal. Yes hes plugged a hole here and there but hes also turned down guys like jahvon quinerly and luther muhammad who wanted to come home! Think about that!

so what’ll now happen. This year we go 3-17 in big ten play and everyone is disappointed but says, “but guys he got us to the tourney and we hadnt been in 3 decades, give him some leash”. Thats just the loser mindset of this fan base because we have buried the bar of what we should expect here. Next year we follow it up with another awful season and now the noise is palpable but we punt the decision one more year. 2023-2024 season is the 3rd straight bad year and we have no choice but to make a coaching change and now the 2024 season starts with a new coach rebuilding taking a few years to get us back to the tourney where we should expect to be every year.

we could start the proper rebuild with a new coach next season but we all know it wont happen for both financial reasons and because of how low the bar is here. But this is inevitable, everyone sees whats coming but we’ll put it off and settle for having a bad team for more years than we need to. I’ll be sure to bump this in march 2024.

One name: Mike Boynton
This post didn't age well at all....just about a complete opposite happened. Pretty remarkable what Pike has accomplished; yes, he will have a challenge in the portal next season, but let's enjoy this now, and maybe we make a little run. Go RU!!
 
This post didn't age well at all....just about a complete opposite happened. Pretty remarkable what Pike has accomplished; yes, he will have a challenge in the portal next season, but let's enjoy this now, and maybe we make a little run. Go RU!!
I do not know why you are so hard on him. At least he got right the part that Pikes a nice guy. Lmao
 
Last edited:
Skinny
We going 1-19 in conference
This post didn't age well at all....just about a complete opposite happened. Pretty remarkable what Pike has accomplished; yes, he will have a challenge in the portal next season, but let's enjoy this now, and maybe we make a little run. Go RU!!
Rutgers success under pike the last three years will start to pay dividends in the future. NY & NJ are hot markets for BBALL recruits. Pike has only started to tap into getting higher level recruits like Mulcahy and Cliff. Now that pike got an extension recruits know he is going to stay awhile. Also, it is well known that pike is one of the best coaches for developing players. Recruiting should get better and better.
 
Rutgers success under pike the last three years will start to pay dividends in the future. NY & NJ are hot markets for BBALL recruits. Pike has only started to tap into getting higher level recruits like Mulcahy and Cliff. Now that pike got an extension recruits know he is going to stay awhile. Also, it is well known that pike is one of the best coaches for developing players. Recruiting should get better and better.
You dont understand the recruiting landscape locally here. The aau circuit locally doesnt view pike in high regards. You might not like it, agree with it, but dont shoot the messenger here.
 
You dont understand the recruiting landscape locally here. The aau circuit locally doesnt view pike in high regards. You might not like it, agree with it, but dont shoot the messenger here.
you know 1 or 2 guys (if that), and now you're speaking for the entire local AAU circuit?

GTFOH

I know a couple of AAU guys and they love him.

In Edit: and I can say that AND acknowledge that recruiting needs to improve
 
You dont understand the recruiting landscape locally here. The aau circuit locally doesnt view pike in high regards. You might not like it, agree with it, but dont shoot the messenger here.
Big picture, do you wish we didn't make it? I have not seen any posts from you about the tournament since the bracket was announced. The search function says you posted about the Army cadets and that we missed JY this year (and he missed us), and that's it since the selection show.
 
Big picture, do you wish we didn't make it? I have not seen any posts from you about the tournament since the bracket was announced. The search function says you posted about the Army cadets and that we missed JY this year (and he missed us), and that's it since the selection show.
He and Mike Boynton are together crying in their beers
 
You dont understand the recruiting landscape locally here. The aau circuit locally doesnt view pike in high regards. You might not like it, agree with it, but dont shoot the messenger here.
It's not about Pikiell it's about Rutgers. And to be honest Seton Hall has this problem too. At least for now, RU and SHU are not sexy places for those with the power to steer kids toward. Every so often you break through with a Cliff or a Whitehead but that's what we're dealing with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rubigtimenow
You dont understand the recruiting landscape locally here. The aau circuit locally doesnt view pike in high regards. You might not like it, agree with it, but dont shoot the messenger here.

This is again where credibility gets questioned and is very vague and a rumor mill that no one can validate. Anyone can find more than a few AAU coaches who ALL think they're better coaches than college assistant coaches. The AAU circuit is a hard working group and they do a lot to get kids scholarship opportunities.

At the same time, it costs money to get AAU coaches on your side and this is how ill advised kyk1827 is about college hoops recruiting.

The AAU coaches are also ego-driven and it's as political as anything else. If any college program shows anything close to an allegiance or favoritism for one vs the other dozen or so programs, you wind up losing anyway. That's why this notion that you need to "pay" or cozy up to any one AAU affiliate, is dumb.

You can work and recruit with the circuits that support your brand or work with the relationships earned over time with your assistant coaches. If there is a Nike run AAU affiliate, it is very difficult to land kids when you're not a Nike school or vice versa.....and AAU affiliate as a reliable way of recruiting is BAD in terms of building a program. If that program has a questionable player or bad fit, the AAU program is going to expect you to take that player anyway.

RU is building a program, not an AAU reliant coaching staff. You build a program based on investment in each recruit, one player or person at a time. That's the stable and reliable way, and how RU has gotten here today.
 
This is again where credibility gets questioned and is very vague and a rumor mill that no one can validate. Anyone can find more than a few AAU coaches who ALL think they're better coaches than college assistant coaches. The AAU circuit is a hard working group and they do a lot to get kids scholarship opportunities.

At the same time, it costs money to get AAU coaches on your side and this is how ill advised kyk1827 is about college hoops recruiting.

The AAU coaches are also ego-driven and it's as political as anything else. If any college program shows anything close to an allegiance or favoritism for one vs the other dozen or so programs, you wind up losing anyway. That's why this notion that you need to "pay" or cozy up to any one AAU affiliate, is dumb.

You can work and recruit with the circuits that support your brand or work with the relationships earned over time with your assistant coaches. If there is a Nike run AAU affiliate, it is very difficult to land kids when you're not a Nike school or vice versa.....and AAU affiliate as a reliable way of recruiting is BAD in terms of building a program. If that program has a questionable player or bad fit, the AAU program is going to expect you to take that player anyway.

RU is building a program, not an AAU reliant coaching staff. You build a program based on investment in each recruit, one player or person at a time. That's the stable and reliable way, and how RU has gotten here today.
Curious. What’s the strategy with the Hall in terms of recruiting and AAU? More often than not, they seem to field quality teams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUSK97
I’m glad this board is filled with Nostradamus’ that knew we were an NCAA tournament team after we played Lafayette, UMass, and DePaul.

You guys are THE BEST Rutgers fans on this board, so much better than everyone else. Honestly, it’s remarkable @kyk1827 and every poster that questioned the team even doubted them when they were playing like they’ve never played organized basketball before.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_0k9zlfz6lz9oy
Do you guys realize that you need to be good before you can actually start landing multiple big time recruits? Or you need to cheat. That is not pikiell though. Why would an AAU coach send their kids to Rutgers when they could easily send them to another school that consistently gets to the ncaa tournament? AAU coaches wont even take your call for certain kids if they know your program is trash. i.e. Rutgers 6 years ago.

Pikiell is doing exactly what he needs to do to win. That is to look for under valued kids who can play at our level. Quite honestly that is exactly what iowa does and purdue. we need to be like them. That is who we are right now.

for example, Keegan Murray's only major conference offer was iowa because his dad played there. He was a mid major recruit. 3 star
 
I’m glad this board is filled with Nostradamus’ that knew we were an NCAA tournament team after we played Lafayette, UMass, and DePaul.

You guys are THE BEST Rutgers fans on this board, so much better than everyone else. Honestly, it’s remarkable @kyk1827 and every poster that questioned the team even doubted them when they were playing like they’ve never played organized basketball before.
Questioning the team =/= “Pike should be fired after this year”
 
Questioning the team =/= “Pike should be fired after this year”
That’s a fair point, but regardless you’re still viewing through the lens of today when everyone knows that’s a load of bs considering when these threads were started.
 
It was premature at best then too
You’re probably right, but it speaks to the passion of the fan base IMO.

Everyone on this board cares about Rutgers sports more than the majority of the people we meet every day.

We’re all absolute psychos and a lot of people took this year really badly early on, especially when the season was super hyped.

The people bumping it are doing so acting as if they’re better fans than others and it’s comical. No body on this board wants anything but success for RU athletics.
 
Curious. What’s the strategy with the Hall in terms of recruiting and AAU? More often than not, they seem to field quality teams.
Bryce Aiken - Harvard transfer
Kadary Richmond - Syracuse transfer
Ike Obiagu - Florida State transfer
Alexis Yetna - South Florida transfer
Tray Jackson - Missouri transfer
Jamir Harris - American transfer
Jared Rhoden - #199 prospect
Tyrese Samuel - #184 prospect (also, from Canada)
Myles Cale - #92 recruit

Willard isn't really playing the AAU game at least not lately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ruman
Curious. What’s the strategy with the Hall in terms of recruiting and AAU? More often than not, they seem to field quality teams.

Not sure if you mean Seton Hall doing something different than RU. What gives you the impression they're doing something different than RU?? SHU made the likely tournament in 2019-20, missed the NCAAs last year and are back this year. Prior to last year, fueled by some obvious recruiting violations with NYCs Isiah Whitehead, they landed a strong class 5 or 6 years ago that rebuilt their program. SHU landed with a show cause and loss of scholarship or two a couple of years ago, while recruiting Taurean Thompson as a transfer from Syracuse, who ultimately flamed out and did very little for SHU.

SHU landed Jaquan Harris and Sanders, a very good CG out of NYC for 2022. Harris has had knee injuries that slowed his recruitment this past year. But I expect him to recover and be ready for next year.

RU landed Derek Simpson and has Jaden Jones already in the fold. I would take another guard/wing if I was RU, but they're already on top of that right now.

SHU has lived primarily via the transfer portal in the last 2 recruiting cycles,

Bryce Aiken
Kadary Richmond
Tray Jackson
Alexis Yetna
Ike Obiagu
Jamir Harris

That makes up a good amount of their minutes in the last year or two, but it's all via the portal.....which is 100% fine if that's what suits the staff for putting a roster together.....SHU has some pieces like RU, that just couldn't find minutes, but those players should have a chance to play next year.

I don't necessarily think there's one way to assemble a roster, but there's is really only one way to build a program.....RU is attempting to build a program, which is via building and creating a culture that fits what the identity or staff wants on and off the court.....vs just slapping together a random roster of pieces or players. There ultimately is a big difference in approach and in time, i believe that to win consistently, building a program is the best approach.
 
Last edited:
I’m glad this board is filled with Nostradamus’ that knew we were an NCAA tournament team after we played Lafayette, UMass, and DePaul.

You guys are THE BEST Rutgers fans on this board, so much better than everyone else. Honestly, it’s remarkable @kyk1827 and every poster that questioned the team even doubted them when they were playing like they’ve never played organized basketball before.

As stated a million times, there’s a difference between questioning the team and posting like a complete troll or dramatic lunatic.

Not sure why you still can’t see that difference.
 
You’re probably right, but it speaks to the passion of the fan base IMO.

Everyone on this board cares about Rutgers sports more than the majority of the people we meet every day.

We’re all absolute psychos and a lot of people took this year really badly early on, especially when the season was super hyped.

The people bumping it are doing so acting as if they’re better fans than others and it’s comical. No body on this board wants anything but success for RU athletics.
Hopefully it's a learning point for the chicken littles who said the season was over after only a few games. Teams develop and fans need to be patient and have some faith in Pike and the players.
 
This thread just validates once again how lost KYk was and still is. He and a few other RIPPED Coach Pikiell up and down and wanted him fired in November. A few guys just take things to another level after one or two bad games. They should get off the ledge. Steve is an excellent coach and I am so glad he is our Basketball coach at Rutgers.
 
how many of these threads are going to get bumped again, when they were bumped the previous dozen times, now a few of them again, its so silly
This one is getting bumped and talked about because the OP loved dumping on Pike all season, including last week with threads saying our non-conference scheduling would cost us a bid. Now that we are in, he hasn't posted a single "mea culpa" or anything that looks like praise for Pike and the team for clawing their way back to the dance.
 
Not sure if you mean Seton Hall doing something different than RU. What gives you the impression they're doing something different than RU?? SHU made the likely tournament in 2019-20, missed the NCAAs last year and are back this year. Prior to last year, fueled by some obvious recruiting violations with NYCs Isiah Whitehead, they landed a strong class 5 or 6 years ago that rebuilt their program. SHU landed with a show cause and loss of scholarship or two a couple of years ago, while recruiting Taurean Thompson as a transfer from Syracuse, who ultimately flamed out and did very little for SHU.

SHU landed Jaquan Harris and Sanders, a very good CG out of NYC for 2022. Harris has had knee injuries that slowed his recruitment this past year. But I expect him to recover and be ready for next year.

RU landed Derek Simpson and has Jaden Jones already in the fold. I would take another guard/wing if I was RU, but they're already on top of that right now.

SHU has lived primarily via the transfer portal in the last 2 recruiting cycles,

Bryce Aiken
Kadary Richmond
Tray Jackson
Alexis Yetna
Ike Obiagu
Jamir Harris

That makes up a good amount of their minutes in the last year or two, but it's all via the portal.....which is 100% fine if that's what suits the staff for putting a roster together.....SHU has some pieces like RU, that just couldn't find minutes, but those players should have a chance to play next year.

I don't necessarily think there's one way to assemble a roster, but there's is really only one way to build a program.....RU is attempting to build a program, which is via building and creating a culture that fits what the identity or staff wants on and off the court.....vs just slapping together a random roster of pieces or players. There ultimately is a big difference in approach and in time, i believe that to win consistently, building a program is the best approach.
Agree 100%. Thanks for the perspective and analysis.
 
You’re probably right, but it speaks to the passion of the fan base IMO.

Everyone on this board cares about Rutgers sports more than the majority of the people we meet every day.

We’re all absolute psychos and a lot of people took this year really badly early on, especially when the season was super hyped.

The people bumping it are doing so acting as if they’re better fans than others and it’s comical. No body on this board wants anything but success for RU athletics.
I’d go to war for Pike but agree that we have probably one of the best basketball boards/board communities out there. I’d also say that the fans at the RAC are more knowledgeable and tuned in than most other fanbases.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The RUT
You’re probably right, but it speaks to the passion of the fan base IMO.

Everyone on this board cares about Rutgers sports more than the majority of the people we meet every day.

We’re all absolute psychos and a lot of people took this year really badly early on, especially when the season was super hyped.

The people bumping it are doing so acting as if they’re better fans than others and it’s comical. No body on this board wants anything but success for RU athletics.
The "passion of the fan base" is used way too frequently as an excuse for poor behavior. And while I agree that everyone cares about Rutgers sports, we're not all "absolute psychos." The majority are actually quite rational and reasonable...and are able to express frustration and disappointment without becoming completely unhinged.
 
That’s a fair point, but regardless you’re still viewing through the lens of today when everyone knows that’s a load of bs considering when these threads were started.
Nah..its one thing to have reasonable disagreements

A bunch of folks (you included at times) were burying the coach and program while it was still breathing...while many of us were simply saying wait until the exam is over before grading it

Major major fail by many many posters

Hope you guys learn from it (especially you since you posted 2 years IN A ROW we wouldn't make the tournament)
 
Big picture, do you wish we didn't make it? I have not seen any posts from you about the tournament since the bracket was announced. The search function says you posted about the Army cadets and that we missed JY this year (and he missed us), and that's it since the selection show.
Haha follow me on twitter. I dont run here and post every thought i have.


 
This one is getting bumped and talked about because the OP loved dumping on Pike all season, including last week with threads saying our non-conference scheduling would cost us a bid. Now that we are in, he hasn't posted a single "mea culpa" or anything that looks like praise for Pike and the team for clawing their way back to the dance.
Youre wrong. I said if we missed the tourney it was because of the out of conference schedule. Like hours later wachtel, one of the top bracketologists literally tweeted the same exact thing
 
Nah..its one thing to have reasonable disagreements

A bunch of folks (you included at times) were burying the coach and program while it was still breathing...while many of us were simply saying wait until the exam is over before grading it

Major major fail by many many posters

Hope you guys learn from it (especially you since you posted 2 years IN A ROW we wouldn't make the tournament)
I don’t hide from my previous posts, you know that. That’s fine you think they were unwarranted, but IMO when people were killing the team, they earned it.

The only crime from the negatives posts is that some of those guys didn’t come back to praise the team when they got it going, and I will absolutely give you that.

As far as the exam is over point, that’s fair, but keep in mind we made NCAA history this year. All 4 of those ranked wins were required to make the tourney after our start, and no one saw that coming.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT