ADVERTISEMENT

OT: 2024 NY Yankees Season Thread

I'm still trying to figure out the logic of walking Devers with no one on base???
IMO the walk to O'Neill was the problem. Followed by the ball down the left field line barely fair by Yoshida.
Then Cole folded.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MitchLL
Give me some ideas...What's the pitching rotation for the post season based on the current performance?

Most teams use a three man rotation, I believe.
 
Great to take 3 of 4 from Boston and hopefully put an end to their hopes for making the playoffs.
Boston manager is a cheating a-hole.
On to Seattle.... Gil, Cortez, and Schmidt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MitchLL and Vlife
Cole, Rodon, Cortes.
Boone's gonna have some tough decisions to make.

Right now, Cole is not pitching anywhere near good enough to be a top 3 pitcher.
And I think he's a "headcase" right now with no confidence as exhibited in his decision to intentionally walk Devers.
He might go ballistic if not the SP1 or SP2.
Personally, I'd go Rodon, Cortez, and Gil.
Cortez needs to pitch in Yankee Stadium.
 
Boone's gonna have some tough decisions to make.

Right now, Cole is not pitching anywhere near good enough to be a top 3 pitcher.
And I think he's a "headcase" right now with no confidence as exhibited in his decision to intentionally walk Devers.
He might go ballistic if not the SP1 or SP2.
Personally, I'd go Rodon, Cortez, and Gil.
Cortez needs to pitch in Yankee Stadium.
Cole is the GUY no matter what the situation is. and, any given game, he can go 7 inn 3 hit 10 k 1 run - it does put Boone in a tough situation- "headcase" does not apply to someone like Cole- it is either physical or mechanical. But maybe- he needs some sort of break or maybe just go with the confidence. That is most likely the only real way to go with Cole.

You sit him and you don't win- you piss him off and you lose your job. You sit him and win- you piss him off. You play him and he doesn't perform, you may still lose your job. But, Cole is not in his head unless there is still a physical issue
 
I can't believe that it's even a question with some Yankees fans as to whether or not Cole is the Yankees best pitcher.
 
Boone's gonna have some tough decisions to make.

Right now, Cole is not pitching anywhere near good enough to be a top 3 pitcher.
And I think he's a "headcase" right now with no confidence as exhibited in his decision to intentionally walk Devers.
He might go ballistic if not the SP1 or SP2.
Personally, I'd go Rodon, Cortez, and Gil.
Cortez needs to pitch in Yankee Stadium.

I think you might be a bit harsh on Cole based on his last outing/recency bias and a bad outing against the Red Sox. Note that all pitchers tend to have bad outings, even Cy Young winners

He's started 15 games this year since coming off the IL.
  • Only given up over 3 earned runs 4 times in those starts.
  • Conversely he gave up 2 or less earned runs 10 times this season in 15 starts.
  • In his prior 7 starts to the Red Sox game he had a 1.6 ERA with an average of 5 2/3 innings with 47 strikeouts (1.2 per inning) & 12 BB's (1.7 per start).
He had 3 stinkers early on during his return to the mound after IL - this adversely impacted his ERA. However recently it's hard to judge him solely on one outing as it seems as if he's returning to form.

Also note that from an effectiveness standpoint (IMO) Cortez would probably be better than Cole out of the Penn. He might make a great lefty specialist - who can also go long on innings in the playoffs
 
  • Like
Reactions: MitchLL
I think you might be a bit harsh on Cole based on his last outing/recency bias and a bad outing against the Red Sox. Note that all pitchers tend to have bad outings, even Cy Young winners

He's started 15 games this year since coming off the IL.
  • Only given up over 3 earned runs 4 times in those starts.
  • Conversely he gave up 2 or less earned runs 10 times this season in 15 starts.
  • In his prior 7 starts to the Red Sox game he had a 1.6 ERA with an average of 5 2/3 innings with 47 strikeouts (1.2 per inning) & 12 BB's (1.7 per start).
He had 3 stinkers early on during his return to the mound after IL - this adversely impacted his ERA. However recently it's hard to judge him solely on one outing as it seems as if he's returning to form.

Also note that from an effectiveness standpoint (IMO) Cortez would probably be better than Cole out of the Penn. He might make a great lefty specialist - who can also go long on innings in the playoffs
get out of here with facts- they always ruin good stories lol
 
Clay Holmes doing Clay Holmes stuff.

He should only be pitching when they're up 8 runs or down 8 runs.
 
Last edited:
Holmes is a BUM! Freakin idiot
Weaver hadn't pitched since Saturday.
Boone got lucky with the Arozorena strike out and could've yanked Holmes on the spot. There was no advantage to leaving Holmes in. Weaver was ready.

Bad managing and still lucked out and got the win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 93RUDoc
The Orioles lost again tonight. What happened to them ?
They've sucked since somebody on one of the broadcasts said they were the most talented team in the league.
Like I said in an earlier post in this thread, it's amazing what you can do when you get great starting pitching.
 
Clay Holmes doing Clay Holmes stuff.

He should only be pitching when they're up 8 runs or down 8 runs.
Holmes is always good for.....

giphy.gif
 
Boone should have kept the Martian on the roster from the minute he was healthy enough to return.
If he's your future, he needs reps in the OF.

Imagine Boone managing on a team with less talent and a small payroll?
 
I hope Brian Cashman was watching today's game to see what a "closer" looks like, as in Seattle's!

And just noticed, the NYY struck out 37X in a three game series.
That's a problem in the playoffs.
 
  • Love
Reactions: RUfinally2008
I hope Brian Cashman was watching today's game to see what a "closer" looks like, as in Seattle's!

And just noticed, the NYY struck out 37X in a three game series.
That's a problem in the playoffs.
Seattle hitters struck out 32 times in those three games.
BTW, Seattle has the best team ERA in MLB.
And the Yankees won two of the three games. They would have won all three if their left fielder could catch the friggin ball.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TRU2RU
Seattle hitters struck out 32 times in those three games.
BTW, Seattle has the best team ERA in MLB.
And the Yankees won two of the three games. They would have won all three if their left fielder could catch the friggin ball.
They would have probably lost a game if J-Rod wasn't a freakin' idiot. It works both ways.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MitchLL
I hope Brian Cashman was watching today's game to see what a "closer" looks like, as in Seattle's!

And just noticed, the NYY struck out 37X in a three game series.
That's a problem in the playoffs.
Cashman prefers the home run hitter, over the contact hitter, thus the strike outs that comes with it.
 
Cashman prefers the home run hitter, over the contact hitter, thus the strike outs that comes with it.
Looking at the lineup it's hard to believe he prefers the home run hitter.
Have you seen Trevino, Rizzo, Torres, Volpe, Verdugo mashing this season ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUfinally2008
Looking at the lineup it's hard to believe he prefers the home run hitter.
Have you seen Trevino, Rizzo, Torres, Volpe, Verdugo mashing this season ?
Don't forget Stanton, who once again struck out last nite with a runner on 3rd with <2 outs!
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT