Positives:No Cashman started as a good GM and has turned into a horrible GM. Good? On the 2021 team what was a good pick up? I can give 5* worse pickups.
Clay Holmes - 1.61 ERA for Yanks
Wandy Peralta - 2.95 ERA for Yanks
Middle of the Road:
Anthony Rizzo .249 average, 8 HR's for Yanks
Joey Gallo - .160 BA, 13 HR's and 88 K's for Yanks
That doesn't exactly scream horrible to me. It screams, my time has run out here, maybe it's time for a fresh perspective and new blood for the Yankees.
You do realize that if Cashman leaves say next year at the end of his contract, 75 percent of the teams in MLB would immediately try to hire him, right? There's also the problem of who exactly are the Yanks going to hire as his replacement when needed. It's a 50/50 shot you get someone good, it's less than that to hire someone spectacular.