ADVERTISEMENT

OT: Why the real estate market is not in a bubble: Q1 2023 update video added to OP

Kyk - I work within the acquisitions group for a large publicity traded real estate investment company , one of the companies buying the most single family residential homes nationwide - i will tell you that I disagree with you strongly on your take on the market here. But then again, I’m based out of Arizona and we don’t really invest a whole lot in NJ.

A month ago I would admitted that I know some very smart people who think I’m wrong , but even they are starting to see weakness in the RE market now as well.
Arizona is one market we will see price drops along with vegas. Inventory climbing crazy high after appreciation was near all time highs past 2 years.

do you guys buy multi-family? We have a 120 unit complex for sale in Glendale, call for offers this week curious if you took a look/take a look there
 
With all the uproar over the salt write off limits when Republicans were in office , why hasn't that been repealed? Now with rates shooting sky high, it's a double whammy as folks can't offset some of it like they used to in the historical charts everyone is citing
 
Arizona is one market we will see price drops along with vegas. Inventory climbing crazy high after appreciation was near all time highs past 2 years.

do you guys buy multi-family? We have a 120 unit complex for sale in Glendale, call for offers this week curious if you took a look/take a look there
I was doing this in back in 2006 and remember it well - I agree it will be AZ , Vegas and FL again to lead the decline.

We do not do any mutifamily
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon_0k9zlfz6lz9oy
That was the early 1990's crash. Parent's home- house was not for sale in 1988, and some person randomly knocked on the door and offered my parents $800K for a house on the river. They declined. Four years later in 1992, they decided they had to sell--for less than $360K. Timing is everything.

First place we owned was a townhouse in Middlesex County we bought in 1992 for $98K. Sold it for $90-92K in 1995.

Some historical perspective.

From a 2018 Forbes article:

"In conclusion, a correction of home prices is likely at some point and the next recession could be a trigger like the 1990 recession was to some degree."

CS-5-Cities-IA.jpg

Interesting graphic. I'm assuming it would show house values back up around the 2006 peak, now, if the graph was extended from 2018 to 2022 (for most of those cities). Inflation is up about 38%, cumulatively, since the 2006 house value peak and I know our house value is up over 38% since 2006. If we were smart and motivated, we'd downsize now and pocket some profit with the likely coming downturn. But we're maybe moderately smart and certainly not motivated, lol.
 
The stagflation of the 1970's may be the template for our immediate horizon. Interesting -- according to a chart I just saw -- homes prices corrected down in the first half of the 70's, then shot upwards int he second half before plummeting down again, probably when Voelker jacked up rates so high.

Although RE is a good inflation hedge, you'll see prices correct down with increased mortgage rates and inventories go up. That's just common sense. You're already starting to see this happen.

An interesting question in my mind, with the oldest Boomers past 80 now, will that eventually increase inventory as they downsize, go into assisted living ect.?
 
The stagflation of the 1970's may be the template for our immediate horizon. Interesting -- according to a chart I just saw -- homes prices corrected down in the first half of the 70's, then shot upwards int he second half before plummeting down again, probably when Voelker jacked up rates so high.

Although RE is a good inflation hedge, you'll see prices correct down with increased mortgage rates and inventories go up. That's just common sense. You're already starting to see this happen.

An interesting question in my mind, with the oldest Boomers past 80 now, will that eventually increase inventory as they downsize, go into assisted living ect.?

Prices corrected down after the 1973-4 Oil Embargo tanked the economy and then recovered in the second half and bottom fell out in NYC because of the city's financial crisis.

Oldest Boomers are actually 76.
 
Kyk - I work within the acquisitions group for a large publicity traded real estate investment company , one of the companies buying the most single family residential homes nationwide - i will tell you that I disagree with you strongly on your take on the market here. But then again, I’m based out of Arizona and we don’t really invest a whole lot in NJ.

A month ago I would admitted that I know some very smart people who think I’m wrong , but even they are starting to see weakness in the RE market now as well.
Not many posters agree with Kyle from what I see. The rental market will be strong because people can’t afford the mortgage to buy a house.
 
The stagflation of the 1970's may be the template for our immediate horizon. Interesting -- according to a chart I just saw -- homes prices corrected down in the first half of the 70's, then shot upwards int he second half before plummeting down again, probably when Voelker jacked up rates so high.

Although RE is a good inflation hedge, you'll see prices correct down with increased mortgage rates and inventories go up. That's just common sense. You're already starting to see this happen.

An interesting question in my mind, with the oldest Boomers past 80 now, will that eventually increase inventory as they downsize, go into assisted living ect.?
Retirees that can still live in their home will stay in their home. I’m a boomers with several siblings and none will leave their home unless they have too due to some disability as they age. The assisted living and nursing homes are also so expensive. I guess there a quite a few families that sign over their homes to the nursing homes, I know a few. We checked out the price for the nursing home after my father rehab and it was $13k a month or $156k a year.
 
Last edited:
I don’t see existing home sale inventory moving up dramatically because where are those sellers going to go?

If you have a home valued at $1M with a $600K refinanced mortgage with a 3.25% rate, you’re paying $2,600. If you then go buy a $1.2M house with a 5.5% rate currently you’re probably looking at a $4,500 payment. Are you going to move? F no!
 
Interesting graphic. I'm assuming it would show house values back up around the 2006 peak, now, if the graph was extended from 2018 to 2022 (for most of those cities). Inflation is up about 38%, cumulatively, since the 2006 house value peak and I know our house value is up over 38% since 2006. If we were smart and motivated, we'd downsize now and pocket some profit with the likely coming downturn. But we're maybe moderately smart and certainly not motivated, lol.
I know somebody who did what you contemplated. House across the street sold, and the realtor knew them, knocked on the door and said their house could be sold quickly for $1.1M. It was sold in a week. They downsized to a house around the corner for $500-550K, and took the money and ran. Not a bad sum of cash to be sitting on when the equities markets are tanking.
 
Retirees that can still live in their home will stay in their home. I’m a boomers with several siblings and none will leave their home unless they have too due to some disability as they age. The assisted living and nursing homes are also so expensive. I guess there a quite a few families that sign over their homes to the nursing homes, I know a few. We checked out the price for the nursing home after my father rehab and it was $13k a month or $156k a year.
No long term care insurance? We bought some when younger when it was cheap, but it will probably be quite worthless if/when we need it.
 
No, but they wouldn’t want to go unless they have to go. I took care of my father before he passed at 97 and currently assisting my mother at 91.
For a lot of people, this is the best way, emotionally and financially. It can be a lot of work, and in most instances, it is worth it.
 
Not many posters agree with Kyle from what I see. The rental market will be strong because people can’t afford the mortgage to buy a house.

Actually I think not having the down payment might be as large or larger factor, particularly in '16-'19 when rates were so low. A lot of the rents of high end places could cover the mortgage and taxes of some decent properties.
 
Interesting graphic. I'm assuming it would show house values back up around the 2006 peak, now, if the graph was extended from 2018 to 2022 (for most of those cities). Inflation is up about 38%, cumulatively, since the 2006 house value peak and I know our house value is up over 38% since 2006. If we were smart and motivated, we'd downsize now and pocket some profit with the likely coming downturn. But we're maybe moderately smart and certainly not motivated, lol.
Dont compare to mid 2000’s compare to late 70’s. Take a gander at this piece https://calculatedrisk.substack.com/p/comparing-the-current-housing-market?s=r
 
I don’t see existing home sale inventory moving up dramatically because where are those sellers going to go?

If you have a home valued at $1M with a $600K refinanced mortgage with a 3.25% rate, you’re paying $2,600. If you then go buy a $1.2M house with a 5.5% rate currently you’re probably looking at a $4,500 payment. Are you going to move? F no!
Hate to say it but I think we're underestimating the power of layoffs, people are going to be needing to sell. Also I think food cost is going to be a major issue in the future.
 
Not many posters agree with Kyle from what I see. The rental market will be strong because people can’t afford the mortgage to buy a house.
The renting market is absolutely ridiculous, and in return the mortgage business.

Someone can pay 2k a month in rent, but get rejected for a mortgage which would be 1.5k
 
The renting market is absolutely ridiculous, and in return the mortgage business.

Someone can pay 2k a month in rent, but get rejected for a mortgage which would be 1.5k
$839 more per month nationally to own vs rent. These numbers are a couple weeks old though. Its significantly cheaper to rent right now which is why rent growth is rising at all time high numbers
 
Hate to say it but I think we're underestimating the power of layoffs, people are going to be needing to sell. Also I think food cost is going to be a major issue in the future.
Disturbing trend that individual investors are purchasing large chunks of farmland. Bill Gates is most disturbing.

The renting market is absolutely ridiculous, in return the mortgage business.

Someone can pay 2k a month in rent, but get rejected for a mortgage which would be 1.5k
Also disturbing that investors are purchasing large chunks of housing. 18.4% in the fourth quarter of 2021 was purchased by investors.

Subprime mortgages and deregulation f'd regular people over in the last crash. Now investors and the elite are finding another way to f over regular people.
 
Disturbing trend that individual investors are purchasing large chunks of farmland. Bill Gates is most disturbing.


Also disturbing that investors are purchasing large chunks of housing. 18.4% in the fourth quarter of 2021 was purchased by investors.

Subprime mortgages and deregulation f'd regular people over in the last crash. Now investors and the elite are finding another way to f over regular people.
Only 2% of housing is owned by PE/institutions/hedge funds. Large majority 90%+ owned by mom and pop landlords.
 
I know a few. We checked out the price for the nursing home after my father rehab and it was $13k a month or $156k a year.
For that price I'll buy a live in nurse. It'd be a helluva lot more fun than a nursing home especially if I could find a young hot one too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FastMJ
If mortgage rates stay above 6%, housing market is in trouble. It’ll be flat for a while but I see a 15 - 20% decline on starter or 1st homes. The higher end will outperform. Interesting thing will be beach houses. Are they the primary residence post pandemic?
 
If mortgage rates stay above 6%, housing market is in trouble. It’ll be flat for a while but I see a 15 - 20% decline on starter or 1st homes. The higher end will outperform. Interesting thing will be beach houses. Are they the primary residence post pandemic?
My sister in law and a friend are in the high end part of that, one the Hamptons and the other around here.

They both knew things were different when one of the first questions asked is, “how are the schools?”
 
  • Like
Reactions: jtung230
My sister in law and a friend are in the high end part of that, one the Hamptons and the other around here.

They both knew things were different when one of the first questions asked is, “how are the schools?”
Was the answer what schools?
 
My sister in law and a friend are in the high end part of that, one the Hamptons and the other around here.

They both knew things were different when one of the first questions asked is, “how are the schools?”
My parents' mortgage was double 6%. They got by.
 
If mortgage rates stay above 6%, housing market is in trouble. It’ll be flat for a while but I see a 15 - 20% decline on starter or 1st homes. The higher end will outperform. Interesting thing will be beach houses. Are they the primary residence post pandemic?
Markets have priced in rate cuts late 2023. Rates staying even above 5% *should* increase inventory to levels where we have normal rates of appreciation of around 3%/yr and not the current absurd amounts.

just did final and best offers on one of my listings today, 6 offers, we accepted an all cash above asking in the 700’s. Wasnt the highest offers, 3rd highest, but all cash and cash is king
 
If mortgage rates stay above 6%, housing market is in trouble. It’ll be flat for a while but I see a 15 - 20% decline on starter or 1st homes. The higher end will outperform. Interesting thing will be beach houses. Are they the primary residence post pandemic?
You think the higher end will out perform? I have the opposite view. With equity, crypto slaughtering everyone, I feel the low end will continue to have the largest pool of buyers , more people to trade down into it vs the higher end
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT