I don't agree with the bolded statements at all. Straight off the bat recruiting would improve and we'd be having more NJ top 10 stay home due to the cache Schiano brings as a former NFL head coach as well as the charisma he brings. In the BE he already beat out OSU, Michigan, Miami, Alabama, PSU and USC for blue chip recruits. His time away in the NFL will only make him even better.
He had 2 9 win seasons and 1 11 win season in the BE all while pulling in worse recruiting classes than Pitt, Louisville, WVU and USF, with poorer facilities, perception and the threat of being doomed to a non-major conference hanging over his head... Only at the end once he built RU up to a respectable level did he start landing more blue chips.
Here is his record during his time at RU.
2001 Rutgers 2–9 0–7 8th
2002 Rutgers 1–11 0–7 8th
2003 Rutgers 5–7 2–5 7th
2004 Rutgers 4–7 1–5 6th
2005 Rutgers 7–5 4–3 3rd L Insight vs Arizona St.
2006 Rutgers 11–2 5–2 T–2nd W Texas #12 vs Kansas St.
2007 Rutgers 8–5 3–4 T–5th W International vc Ball State
2008 Rutgers 8–5 5–2 T–2nd W Papajohns.com vc NC State
2009 Rutgers 9–4 3–4 T–4th W St. Petersburg vs UCF
2010 Rutgers 4–8 1–6 8th
2011 Rutgers 9–4 4–3 T–4th W Pinstripe vs Iowa St
Total: Rutgers: 68–67 28–48
Total 2005 onward: 56-33 25-24
He would be able to get us into the 7-9 win range in the big ten also imo.
7/8 wins in regular seasons post 2006. The 9-win seasons you reference were 8 regular season wins plus a bowl win. Not a whole lot better than the 8 wins Flood brought us last year.
I want to move forward, not stand still.