Name your favorite spot for a Pizza Pie
- Thread starter cicero grimes
- Start date
Perrulli's, Lake Worth, Texas. Much like the above Omaha entry, it's run by a Jersey transplant. Even the sign out front used to say (haven't been there in decades, so I'm just hoping it's still there) "NEW JERSEY STYLE PIZZA." A full Italian deli as well. A real gem deepintheheartof pure hell on earth.
Pizza Hut Pan Pizza with Pineapples
Papa John's Spinach Alfredo Pizza
Any Mellow Mushroom pizza
These are the best imho.
Papa John's Spinach Alfredo Pizza
Any Mellow Mushroom pizza
These are the best imho.
Zap!!!! Holy Crap!!!! I was a big Kinderhook fan back in the mid 70's!!!!
Every Wednesday at Dodd's and Thursday nights at The Hoffman Beachhouse in Point Pleasant. During the summer thet would do the afternoons back at Hoffman's and I think it was Sam the Band that did the evenings.
As for pizza it may not be the best but I'll still take Spirito's in Elizabeth.
The founder of Santillo's is Mom's Skillethead's grandfather. Al is her cousin. Believe it or not, I've never been there!
Although no longer convenient for me, been going to Manville Pizza off and on for over 40 years. Don't notice a drop and they still make my favorite canzone.
BOCCE CLUB PIZZA Buffalo NY,,,the ONLY thing I like about Buffalo
Ive never had anything as good,,,anywhere
Ive never had anything as good,,,anywhere
I am in Princeton right now and Contes is on the agenda. Thin crust. Not doughy. Fresh ingredients. No bullshit. Can't wait.
I used to live about 10 mins from Contes and am thoroughly pissed I never tried it. They had a powerhouse softball team, and the rivalry kept me from eating there. Didn't realize it was such a favorite, though.
With you,good sir. Brothers FTW. Coffaros aint bad, but with Brothers two mile down 18, not going there!
Yea, I was going to mention Lombari's too as a top choice. I didn't because I like a thinner crust but the problem is that different pizzas are almost like different dishes, just hard to compare. I chose Chitch's and homemade but if I were selecting a medium crust I'd have mentioned Lombardi's. Lubrano, on Easton Ave by 287, is similar and very good too. I'm sorry to say I haven't made it up to Union to Cioffi's but I will try it soon.
I can walk there (and I do walk to the Starbucks nearby all the time) but I have never tried Brooklyn Boys. Will have to give it a shot.
Big fan of Vic's these days. Very thin crust. a large pie is kind of a single serving. Although (as my son found out) two large pies can start to feel like a bit much by the 13th slice or so (he did finish both as a matter of pride).
I really really really hate Greek Pizza!Pizza Athena in Palmer, Alaska is the bomb! They serve pizza there but not pie.
Preps on the OC Boardwalk is my favorite pizza in the world. Manco is a solid top 5.
Di Faras in the Midwood section of Brooklyn. $30 for a plain pie and be prepared to wait in line to get in. Q train to Avenue J gets you within half a block.
When you're done or get tired of waiting, go across the street to Issac's bakery for some excellent Kosher pastry.
When you're done or get tired of waiting, go across the street to Issac's bakery for some excellent Kosher pastry.
Just got 3 large pies from DUSALS in south Brunswick. 2 large plain pies for the kids. 1 large pie with sausage and mushrooms for the parents. And that's exactly how it should be ordered.... Saying pizza is redundant ... I'm calling a pizza place.
My wife who is from perth amboy tells me they did move the entire oven over to south amboy.
Last edited:
Mack and Mancos in OC not sure since the name change.
Primos pizza in Somers Point
Pinos in Woodbridge
Nunzios in Sayreville
Primos pizza in Somers Point
Pinos in Woodbridge
Nunzios in Sayreville
If in Jersey City:
-3 Guys from Italy in Journal Square
-Vincents Pizza JFK Blvd, Greenville section of JC
-Helens Pizza, Downtown JC
Elsewhere:
-Prince Street Pizza, Soho, Manhattan
-Peoples Pizza, Rt 38, Cherry Hill
-3 Guys from Italy in Journal Square
-Vincents Pizza JFK Blvd, Greenville section of JC
-Helens Pizza, Downtown JC
Elsewhere:
-Prince Street Pizza, Soho, Manhattan
-Peoples Pizza, Rt 38, Cherry Hill
Numbers I did enjoy it and have been there many times. If you love an old style bowl of spaghetti and meatballs or sausage theirs is killer as well. Skillet, Is Mrs Skillet from Elizabeth? Spiritos in Port Elizabeth has been there forever and their homeade ravioli is off the chain..
Glad to hear Brothers still around. Started going there when I worked at Pelican back in college. When I graduated and worked in New Brunswick, used to go out of my way to pick up a pie there, through chronic Rt 18 traffic, then all the way home to Princeton area. The vodka sauce pie was worth it, every time. Used to like their mussels back in the day, too.
I r
I tried a square at Mancinis. I was not impressed. It was very ordinary. Maybe a slice would have been the way to go.
I tried a square at Mancinis. I was not impressed. It was very ordinary. Maybe a slice would have been the way to go.
Born, raised and lived in Elizabeth for my first 35 years of life. Spirito's is still going strong. Love the fact that you have to go through the kitchen to get to the bar where the bathrooms are located. A little correction though if someone wants to go there. It's not located in the Port but in the Peterstown section which is locally known as The Burg. Was a big Italian-American neighborhood back in the day. The home of the St. Rocco's Festival every summer before it was shut down because allegedly the boys were skimming a lot of the proceeds. Use to be a highlight of the summer growing up in Elizabeth. Also about two blocks from Spirito's was Centanni's, the original pork store from The Sopranos. Not sure if it's still there.
Had to resurrect this thread. Grossly disappointed by Lombardi's. Went there finally during NCAA wrestling championships at MSG. In Brooklyn I love Roberta's and DiFara. Looking to finally get to L&B Spumoni Gardens soon. In Manhattan I love Adrienne's on Stone Street.
In Jersey love Star Tavern and plan to try Santillo's soon too
Outside NJ love Pepe's, Sally's and Modern in New Haven. All 3 are can't miss!
In Jersey love Star Tavern and plan to try Santillo's soon too
Outside NJ love Pepe's, Sally's and Modern in New Haven. All 3 are can't miss!
Corleone's, International Speedway Blvd at the beach, Daytona. First really good pie i had outside NY/NJ area. I highly recommend.
