My disclaimer is, I have not watched the game and only listened on the radio. That being said, the United States should have enough quality to hold off Panama with 10 men. I understand it is a huge challenge, but I feel that we could have easily parked the bus especially after going up 1-0. That is coaching.
This was surprising to me that Musah did not get on the field. Given his tenacity, I felt he and Aaronson both would have been good subs. I would have taken Reyna off immediately to ensure we have box to box players on the field.
Sargent also - he can play with his back to goal. Ideal to slow the pace of play.
I think Musah or Aaronson probably would've been subbed in, but subbing our GK made the choice much more problematic. Also, the team did okay for the most part, even creating some scoring chances.
But the same critical personnel issue that hurt the team in the last WC is still hurting the team now (and in this game). No depth and thus missing pieces at the back. It's by far the biggest weakness on the team.
The US has quality up front and in the midfield. It has some quality at the back, but one player has a torn ACL, two are really not up to the challenge IMO (Richardson and Scally), and for some reason I have thus far been unable to determine, M Robinson hasn't been playing. I did some web searches but only came up with injuries prior to the last WC. So at the moment, the team is really playing with one quality player at the back in A Rob.
So, IMO, the team lacks quality in perhaps the most crucial places to have it when playing down a man. I'm not sure what role GB has in locating talent for the team. If he's entirely responsible for that, then I would indeed hand him the lion's share of the blame. If it's elements of US Soccer outside of GB (which is what thought it was), then I find it hard to point fingers at him. I refuse to believe we cannot find more capable defenders than Scally and Richardson.
GB's only mistake in this game (and I'm judging it a mistake w/the benefit of hindsight and without 99% of GB's in-depth knowledge of the roster - so my judgement is highly suspect here, was putting Pepi in 10 or 15 minutes too soon. Otherwise, he did what any coach could do with what we had available, IMO. We can make hindsight guesses about what might have worked better (as I just did above). But mostly, that sort of thing is BS. We can't really know.
The talking heads always leap to blame the coach. But if we have to point fingers, I think the blame for that loss falls squarely and entirely on Weah. If the team fails to advance, that probably falls in large part on Weah too, due to his inability to contribute in this final group stage game as a key component of the attack.
And, as I've said many times, Weah's one of my favorite USMNT players. But that was just a massive mental mistake.