ADVERTISEMENT

OT: Official 2021 NY Mets Season Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I know players have seasons where they underperform from their career numbers but this is the first time I can recall an entire team underperforming to this extent. I know injuries have played a role but nobody was really hitting prior to getting hurt. Lindor, Dom and Pete have been relatively healthy and are nowhere near the offensive force I thought they would be.
With the pitching we have had thus far, a normal offense would have us 10 games in front.
 
Our best pure hitter has not hit all season. Even before he got hurt did he look like the Jeff McNeill of the past few years. Let him hit his way up the lineup.
Even then, still only .10 behind Villar with the same OBP...I would bet that with an additional 100 AB's he would be well above Villar. I also like Villar better late for the reasons I gave.
 
Even then, still only .10 behind Villar with the same OBP...I would bet that with an additional 100 AB's he would be well above Villar. I also like Villar better late for the reasons I gave.
I am not arguing Villar vs. McNeil. Villar at 3B and McNeil at 2B They both need to play. I only had Perazza in there because Villar is hurt.
 
I know players have seasons where they underperform from their career numbers but this is the first time I can recall an entire team underperforming to this extent. . . . .
This is just your perception, not reality. The pitching staff has many players outperforming their average year: deGrom, Stroman, Walker, Castro, Loup, etc. Even Diaz is average to a bit better than his average year. The offense has players, mostly backups, playing around their average years, even McCann. Nido is better than he ordinarility is.

Your beef is with certain offensive starters, including Lindor, McNeil, Alonso, Conforto, and Smith. But some have limited playing time because of injuries, including Conforto, McNeil and, less so, Smith. Moreover, Alonso has a limited sample size, with one great year and a lot of struggling since then. If he doesn't learn how to handle breaking stuff, that will continue. On the other hand, Nimmo's numbers are good for him, he's just been injured. Conforto's down too, but he's been injured and has always been a hot or cold guy. JD Davis has just been injured, but he hit when he wasn't.

This is nowhere near an entire team underperforming. The O has some serious contributors underperforming, but many with limited time due to injuries. There's a reason that we're a winning team right now, though, and it's because many are overperforming.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift
This is just your perception, not reality. The pitching staff has many players outperforming their average year: deGrom, Stroman, Walker, Castro, Loup, etc. Even Diaz is average to a bit better than his average year. The offense has players, mostly backups, playing around their average years, even McCann. Nido is better than he ordinarility is.

Your beef is with certain offensive starters, including Lindor, McNeil, Alonso, Conforto, and Smith. But some have limited playing time because of injuries, including Conforto, McNeil and, less so, Smith. Moreover, Alonso has a limited sample size, with one great year and a lot of struggling since then. If he doesn't learn how to handle breaking stuff, that will continue. On the other hand, Nimmo's numbers are good for him, he's just been injured. Conforto's down too, but he's been injured and has always been a hot or cold guy. JD Davis has just been injured, but he hit when he wasn't.

This is nowhere near an entire team underperforming. The O has some serious contributors underperforming, but many with limited time due to injuries. There's a reason that we're a winning team right now, though, and it's because many are overperforming.
We all know he was talking offense…
Davis and Nimmo are the only 2 starters and they have been hurt all year.

McCann semi clise to career numbers but not up to his past 2 years. Every other start AND replacements- are below
 
We all know he was talking offense…
Davis and Nimmo are the only 2 starters and they have been hurt all year.

McCann semi clise to career numbers but not up to his past 2 years. Every other start AND replacements- are below
Right. So you address something different from the "entire team." You pick just offense and exclude more than half the roster. But you go further. You also subdivide your partial list by including only certain offensive players and excluding others. You include players with significant injury time who haven't hit, like McNeil Conforto, and exclude other players with significant injury time who have hit, like Davis and Nimmo. You change the comparator by selecting only McCann's last two years and not the career numbers that the other guy was talking about. You ignore Nido altogether. And you just leave Alfonso's short sample size and worse numbers last year out of the discussion. You're less convincing than the first guy. This is nowhere close to an entire team underperforming their career numbers.
 
Right. So you address something different from the "entire team." You pick just offense and exclude more than half the roster. But you go further. You also subdivide your partial list by including only certain offensive players and excluding others. You include players with significant injury time who haven't hit, like McNeil Conforto, and exclude other players with significant injury time who have hit, like Davis and Nimmo. You change the comparator by selecting only McCann's last two years and not the career numbers that the other guy was talking about. You ignore Nido altogether. And you just leave Alfonso's short sample size and worse numbers last year out of the discussion. You're less convincing than the first guy. This is nowhere close to an entire team underperforming their career numbers.
Well- They did pay McCann based on his last 2 years so that counts. Alonso is pretty much on last year except for a significant power shortage.
Davis and Nimmo up Conforto and McNeil down.
Smith, Lindor way down
So- let’s call it 2 up(Davis/Nimmo) 4 way down(Lindor, Smith, McNeil, Conforto)
2 slightly down (Alonso, McCann)
So- 6 down 2 up. But none of the up guys are playing.
Team hit over .270 last year.,,
Whole F-INg offense is down.pretty simple
Other team scores 3, we most likely lose
 
. . .
Whole F-INg offense is down.pretty simple
. . .
This is basically a complete retreat from the other guy's position.

But we can agree that the offense is down. But offense is down across baseball. But the Mets even more so. Almost the worst offense in the game right now.
 
The best thing that could happen for this kid would be for the offense to step up and give him some early runs to work with. But we know how that idea typically goes.
Well, they got 2 runs for him in the first. He has something to work with now.
 
Kid having moment of his life walking off mound in MLB debut to standing ovation gets interrupted by umpire at foul line to check for illegal substance
 
  • Angry
Reactions: tico brown
Only the Mets recycle guys like Oswalt who don't belong in the majors.
That statement is provably false. EVERY team has "organizational depth" guys who may not be good enough to hold down a regular MLB job, but are in the pool of potential call-ups when you need somebody to hold the fort for a week or two.

Plus, some guys figure it out over time. Chris Flexen seems to have done that. Maybe Oswalt will too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Greg2020
That statement is provably false. EVERY team has "organizational depth" guys who may not be good enough to hold down a regular MLB job, but are in the pool of potential call-ups when you need somebody to hold the fort for a week or two.

Plus, some guys figure it out over time. Chris Flexen seems to have done that. Maybe Oswalt will too.
Must everything have a response? lol
Oswalt has had more than a few opportunities. It might be time to move on to the next guy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT