Football (1966 - 69) was 23-14, capped by the great Centennial Game win over Princeton, 29-0. Rutgers football was just a social event back then, with a well dressed crowd, jackets and ties for men. Very different kind of environment back then, with most of the opponents being programs like Lehigh, Lafayette, Colgate, Columbia, Holy Cross, D2 Delaware, D2 UConn, D2 Boston University (which has since dropped the sport), etc. Not a lot to get excited about aside from the Princeton games, which were always on the road except for the Centennial Game, and an annual game against Army or Navy.
Basketball was another matter, as 1966-70 were the years when RU first experienced the excitement of major college basketball. The four-year record was 70-33 and the 1966-7 season marked RU's first entry into post-season play, making it to the NIT, which back then was still entirely played at the "old" MSG. Young fans won't appreciate it all that much but in that era, the NCAAs had just 23 teams + no conference could have more than one entry. So there were several good teams - ranked teams - in the NIT. NIT week electrified the RU campus and MSG for the entire week of the tournament as the RU team - led by Bobby Lloyd (1st team AA) and Jimmy V - and thousands of fans took over MSG, completely selling out 3 of the 4 appearances, defeating #14 Utah State and #13 New Mexico before falling the Walt Frazier-led SIU, and winning the consolation game over Marshall to finish in 3rd place. That team made me an RU fan for life and for years, Rutgers basketball was my primary sports passion. Sadly, the fervor has gone (I'm not alone in this) and RU football has taken over that position.