Asking an auto manufacturer to build ventilators? It's ridiculous to ask for this kind of volume so quickly. He'll half the parts, at least, are most likely coming from China! Is this just an assembly issue? Are parts procured? Test and assembly fixtures need to be fabricated... I don't people realize what's involved in manufacturing hardware. Ventilators are a bit more complex than let's says masks or some consumable...Sad response from GM and another reason why Trump needs to hold their feet to the fire. GM is promising 1000 new ventilators a week by the end of April, which will likely be way too late for most states, with many already starting to clamor that they're going to run out too (not just NY), which is why this always had to be a Federally led effort. While UK's Dyson, the vacuum company, is planning to deliver 10,000 ventilators by early April. This shouldn't be that hard to do.
https://www.cnn.com/2020/03/26/tech/dyson-ventilators-coronavirus/index.html
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-new...trump-invokes-defense-production-act-n1170881
Well let’s just hypothesize a moment... someone you love gets the virus... they say with this vaccine there is a great outcome of 90 % recovery rate..without it they die.. what would your answer be?There is no way I am putting anything in my body connected at all with the current administration. I trust nothing.
Are you saying we as a country aren’t capable of mass producing this needed item? Sure it takes a restructuring of the process but we do have some smart people working to accomplish this feat... by your screen name CERU00 would imagine you have an RU degree in chemical Engineering from 2000?Asking an auto manufacturer to build ventilators? It's ridiculous to ask for this kind of volume so quickly. He'll half the parts, at least, are most likely coming from China! Is this just an assembly issue? Are parts procured? Test and assembly fixtures need to be fabricated... I don't people realize what's involved in manufacturing hardware. Ventilators are a bit more complex than let's says masks or some consumable...
So that sounds pretty drastic: she's apparently requisitioning the drug that may be effective in treating corona? Has that even been proven yet?Opie said:Our current fascist governor is now the doctor of all doctors and pharmacist of all pharmacists. Made a Hitlerisk order that doctors are not to prescribe a medicine which has been used for decades to treat folks. Pharmacist are not allowed to honor doctors prescriptions for medicine to help the elderly & sick from dying. They are instead to report the doctor. So she can sic State bureaucrats to take their license to practice. So much for freedom in Michigan. And there are people who want to give these fascists total control of our health care.
Well let’s just hypothesize a moment... someone you love gets the virus... they say with this vaccine there is a great outcome of 90 % recovery rate..without it they die.. what would your answer be?
Asking an auto manufacturer to build ventilators? It's ridiculous to ask for this kind of volume so quickly. He'll half the parts, at least, are most likely coming from China! Is this just an assembly issue? Are parts procured? Test and assembly fixtures need to be fabricated... I don't people realize what's involved in manufacturing hardware. Ventilators are a bit more complex than let's says masks or some consumable...
So on one of my muscle car boards had a post from a guy I've known for a long time. He is normally very even keeled, so it was surprising to see this post. He lives in Michigan btw:
So that sounds pretty drastic: she's apparently requisitioning the drug that may be effective in treating corona? Has that even been proven yet?
Thanks, kind of depressing. It's why every country needs its own Dyson, assuming they have one, to step up to innovate to quickly produce ventilators (and hopefully Dyson would share their design to make 10,000 ventilators by next week with others in the interests of humanity, although who knows if others could duplicate that with regard to parts and assembly).@RU848789 here is an excellent interview with the leading manufacturer of ventilators.
https://www.spiegel.de/internationa...ssible-a-549d1e18-8c21-45f1-846f-cf5ca254b008
I don't know if this has been posted but good WaPo article. Focus again on masks and everyone keeping germs in rather than thinking about keeping germs out. That's the kind of "herd action/protection" that could make a difference and slow/stop the spread and flatten the curve. Anything is better than nothing.... mask, bandana, tshirt etc... Can a sneeze or cough project 6 feet or whatever through that barrier if much at all. Didn't realize about the Czech Republic and their mobilization to make sure everyone wears some sort of mask and now it's more frowned upon if you're not wearing one than if you to the point it's now illegal to go out without one.
The article:
When historians tally up the many missteps policymakers have made in response to the coronavirus pandemic, the senseless and unscientific push for the general public to avoid wearing masks should be near the top.
The evidence not only fails to support the push, it also contradicts it. It can take a while for official recommendations to catch up with scientific thinking. In this case, such delays might be deadly and economically disastrous. It’s time to make masks a key part of our fight to contain, then defeat, this pandemic. Masks effective at “flattening the curve” can be made at home with nothing more than a T-shirt and a pair of scissors. We should all wear masks — store-bought or homemade — whenever we’re out in public.
At the height of the HIV crisis, authorities did not tell people to put away condoms. As fatalities from car crashes mounted, no one recommended avoiding seat belts. Yet in a global respiratory pandemic, people who should know better are discouraging Americans from using respiratory protection.
Facing shortages of the N95 masks needed by health-care workers, the U.S. surgeon general announced on Feb. 29 that masks “are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus,” despite significant scientific evidence to the contrary. This is not just a problem in the United States: Even the World Health Organization says, “you only need to wear a mask if you are taking care of a person with suspected 2019-nCoV infection.”
There are good reasons to believe DIY masks would help a lot. Look at Hong Kong, Mongolia, South Korea and Taiwan, all of which have covid-19 largely under control. They are all near the original epicenter of the pandemic in mainland China, and they have economic ties to China. Yet none has resorted to a lockdown, such as in China’s Wuhan province. In all of these countries, all of which were hit hard by the SARS respiratory virus outbreak in 2002 and 2003,
everyone is wearing masks in public. George Gao, director general of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, stated, “Many people have asymptomatic or presymptomatic infections. If they are wearing face masks, it can prevent droplets that carry the virus from escaping and infecting others.”
My data-focused research institute, fast.ai, has found 34 scientific papers indicating basic masks can be effective in reducing virus transmission in public — and not a single paper that shows clear evidence that they cannot.
Studies have documented definitively that in controlled environments like airplanes, people with masks rarely infect others and rarely become infected themselves, while those without masks more easily infect others or become infected themselves.
Masks don’t have to be complex to be effective. A 2013 paper tested a variety of household materials and found that something as simple as two layers of a cotton T-shirt is highly effective at blocking virus particles of a wide range of sizes. Oxford University found evidence this month for the effectiveness of simple fabric mouth and nose covers to be so compelling they now are officially acceptable for use in a hospital in many situations. Hospitals running short of N95-rated masks are turning to homemade cloth masks themselves; if it’s good enough to use in a hospital, it’s good enough for a walk to the store.
The reasons the WHO cites for its anti-mask advice are based not on science but on three spurious policy arguments. First, there are not enough masks for hospital workers. Second, masks may themselves become contaminated and pass on an infection to the people wearing them. Third, masks could encourage people to engage in more risky behavior.
None of these is a good reason to avoid wearing a mask in public.
Yes, there is a shortage of manufactured masks, and these should go to hospital workers. But anyone can make a mask at home by cutting up a cotton T-shirt, tying it back together and then washing it at the end of the day. Another approach, recommended by the Hong Kong Consumer Council, involves rigging a simple mask with a paper towel and rubber bands that can be thrown in the trash at the end of each day.
It’s true that masks can become contaminated. But better a mask gets contaminated than the person who is wearing it. It is not hard to wash or dispose of a mask at the end of the day and then wash hands thoroughly to prevent a contaminated mask from spreading infection.
Finally, the idea that masks encourage risky behavior is nonsensical. We give cars anti-lock brakes and seat belts despite the possibility that people might drive more riskily knowing the safety equipment is there. Construction workers wear hard hats even though the hats presumably could encourage less attention to safety. If any risky behavior does occur, societies have the power to make laws against it.
Many authorities still advise only people with symptoms to wear masks. But this doesn’t help with a disease like covid-19, since a person who does not yet show symptoms can still be contagious. A study in Iceland, where there has been unprecedented levels of testing, found that “about half of those who tested positive [for covid-19] are nonsymptomatic,” according to Iceland’s chief epidemiologist, Thorolfur Gudnason. In fact, in early February, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Director Anthony S. Fauci warned there was strong evidence that covid-19 spreads even among people without symptoms. If we all wear masks, people unknowingly infected with the coronavirus would be less likely to spread it.
I also have heard suggestions that widespread usage of masks in the West will be culturally impossible. The story of the Czech Republic debunks this notion. Social media influencers campaigning to encourage DIY mask creation catalyzed an extraordinary mobilization by nearly the whole population. Within three days, there were enough masks for everyone in the country, and most people were wearing them. This was an entirely grass-roots community effort.
When social distancing requirements forced a small bar in Prague to close, its owner, Štefan Olejár, converted Bar Behind the Curtain into a mask manufacturing facility. He procured sewing machines from the community and makes about 400 cotton masks per day. The bar employs 10 people, including a driver who distributes the masks directly to people who are not able to leave their homes.
There are “mask trees” on street corners around the country, where people hang up masks they have made so others can take them.
The most important message shared in the Czech Republic has been this: “My mask protects you; your mask protects me.” Wearing a mask there is now considered a prosocial behavior. Going outside without one is frowned on as an antisocial action that puts your community at risk. In fact, the community reaction has been so strong that the government has responded by making it illegal to go out in public without a mask.
When I first started wearing a mask in public, I felt a bit odd. But I reminded myself I’m helping my community, and I’m sure in the coming weeks people who don’t wear masks will be the ones who feel out of place. Now I’m trying to encourage everyone to join me — and to get their friends to wear masks, too — with a social media campaign around #masks4all.
Community use of masks alone is not enough to stop the spread. Restrictions on movement and commerce need to stay in place until hospital systems clearly are able to handle the patient load. Then, we need a rigorous system of contact tracing, testing and quarantine of those potentially infected.
Given the weight of evidence, it seems likely that universal mask wearing should be a part of the solution. Every single one of us can make it happen — starting today.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/03/28/masks-all-coronavirus/
Or a bunch of smart students and scientists from MIT, who have announced the design (and prototype as pictured) of an emergency ventilator that can be built for about $100, centered around ambu-bags, which are manually operated devices that deliver air to patients in emergency situations like cardiac arrest and these are readily available in every hospital. The key is the design of a device that can automate the squeezing of the bag in a programmable fashion to deliver air/oxygen, as needed by the patient without having to have someone manually squeeze the bag every few seconds 24/7. Now this is innovation. Maybe GM can build these.Thanks, kind of depressing. It's why every country needs its own Dyson, assuming they have one, to step up to innovate to quickly produce ventilators (and hopefully Dyson would share their design to make 10,000 ventilators by next week with others in the interests of humanity, although who knows if others could duplicate that with regard to parts and assembly).
Asking an auto manufacturer to build ventilators?
Clearly the guy on the muscle car board was posting political BS. This thread has no place for that stuff.So on one of my muscle car boards had a post from a guy I've known for a long time. He is normally very even keeled, so it was surprising to see this post. He lives in Michigan btw:
So that sounds pretty drastic: she's apparently requisitioning the drug that may be effective in treating corona? Has that even been proven yet?
He was asking a simple question and looking for input and got it (and hopefully others now see that the report was inaccurate, which is good) - that's not inherently political.Clearly the guy on the muscle car board was posting political BS. This thread has no place for that stuff.
Summary of today's by presser Cuomo ...
https://www.governor.ny.gov/keywords/health
- 172K tests so far in NY/73K in NYC and 16K/7K (NY/NYC) yesterday
- 59.5K positives so far in NY/33.7K in NYC and 7200/4000 yesterday in NY/NYC (7600/4300 day before) – this is the first time we’ve seen a decrease in new cases in either NY or NYC, since cases started rising quickly. Great news! This is not yet the “peak” since hospitalization/ICU cases are still increasing, as per below, but it’s a good sign that maybe the peak will not be the modeled peak – if the current interventions are maintained.
- 965 total deaths in NY so far, up 237 from yesterday (was up 209 two days ago) and this is likely to keep increasing, as deaths lag cases by 2-4 weeks.
- Total of 8500 currently hospitalized in NY (1200 new vs. 847 yesterday and 1100 2 days ago)
- Hospitalization rate doubling every 6 days, looking at last 3 days data (was every 2 days a week ago), so rate of increase has decreased significantly and possibly leveled off, which is good.
- Total of 2037 currently in ICU, which means on ventilators usually; this is 272 new vs. 172 new yesterday and 374 new 2 days ago (bouncing around as expected),
- Total of 3572 discharged (2726 as of yesterday, so 846 discharged yesterday – rate is increasing
- 80% of cases continue to self resolve or mild symptoms resolving at home
- Total of 59.5K cases in NY, 11K in NJ, 5500 in CA, 4600 in MI, 4300 in WA, 4300 in MA, 4000 in FL, 3500 in IL, 3300 in LA, 2800 in PA - most of these other states now accelerating faster than NY.
- CDC ordered travel advisory for NY/NJ/CT (not a lockdown) to be implemented by states to discourage all travel, which he supports and NY/NJ/CT have implemented. RI dropped their “quarantine on New Yorkers” exective order and Trump dropped his "quarantine" talk.
- Quoted FDR: “courage is not the absence of fear, but rather the assessment that something else is more important than fear.”
It has nothing to do with intelligence. In a typical medical device there many many integral parts. Many are custom and many arent off the shelf. Aside from the components, there is so much more work that goes into starting up a manufacturing line. All of it takes time. GM knows nothing about medical devices! Ask a freaking medical company to do this, not GM.Are you saying we as a country aren’t capable of mass producing this needed item? Sure it takes a restructuring of the process but we do have some smart people working to accomplish this feat... by your screen name CERU00 would imagine you have an RU degree in chemical Engineering from 2000?
It has nothing to do with intelligence. In a typical medical device there many many integral parts. Many are custom and many arent off the shelf. Aside from the components, there is so much more work that goes into starting up a manufacturing line. All of it takes time. GM knows nothing about medical devices! Ask a freaking medical company to do this, not GM.
I actually have a Ceramic Engineering degree (since changed to Materials Engineering) and work as a manufacturing Engineer for a high technology medical device manufacturer.
This could be “Apollo 13 - Part II”
“The gravity of the situation is heavier this time...”
(sounds much better when you read it in a voice like the “In a World....” guy does)
https://www.governor.ny.gov/keywords/health
- 66.5K positives in NY so far, and 7000 new cases in NY yesterday (7200 new the day before) so another slight decrease in new cases. This is not yet the “peak” since hospitalization/ICU cases are still increasing, as per below, but it’s a good sign that maybe the peak will not be the modeled peak and won’t generally exceed current hospital capacities (except in local situations) – if the current interventions are maintained – but they still need to supply for the peak, in case compliance wanes and/or rates go back up.
- 2738 total deaths in the US and 1218 total deaths in NY, up 253 from yesterday (was up 237 two days ago); 161 deaths in NJ so far
- Total of 9500 currently hospitalized (1000 new vs. 1200 new yesterday),
- Total of 2352 in ICU (315 new vs. 272 new yesterday
- Total of 4204 discharged vs. 3572 as of yesterday, so 632 discharged yesterday vs. 846 the day before and 681 two days ago (could just be fluctuations).
- Now hospitalization rate still doubling every 6 days, looking at last 3 days data (was 2, then 4 b4), so rate of increase has clearly leveled off, which is good.
- No NYC data shared today and no testing data shared today (not sure why)
- 80% self resolve or mild symptoms resolving at home
- 149K cases in the US: 66.5K in NY, 13.4K in NJ, 6300 in CA, 5500 in MI, 4900 in WA, 4900 in MA, 4900 in FL, 4600 in IL, 3500 in LA, 3400 in PA
- Making progress on supplies, but difficult with 50 states, feds, hospitals all competing; vents now $50K (was $20K); it’s too late to prepare when the storm hits.
- Public has to be more responsible with staying at home and keeping 6’ away from people when one has to go out; might have to close some playgrounds (too dense)
- Support our “troops” – health care workers, first responders, essential personnel, etc.
- His goal is to engage the POTUS as a partner and not to play politics; has praised him many times, but will also point out shortfalls; “no red and blue, only red, white and blue and we’re in a national emergency, a war”
Am I glad I never saw that trailer: it gave too much away.
Today (Saturday), the State is reporting a total of 29882 tests performed, for an increase of 4979 tests since yesterday. That is a decline in the daily testing rate. (Note that the Health Commissioner says that only about 90% of the reported test results include both positive and negative tests, and the remaining 10% only include positive, so there is a small gap in the number total tests and the number of negative results.)
The State is also reporting that 34.99% of the tests were positive, a continued increase in positive rate. As I previously commented, I think this is an indication that there is pent-up demand for tests because testing criteria is too stringent and not enough tests are being performed.
I think the state needs to increase testing to at least 7500 tests per day by late next week. Hopefully some of the new testing protocols will enable an increase in testing, and also much faster turn-around in reporting results.
Monday, the State is reporting 40,806 total tests conducted, which represents an increase of 5780 on Sunday and 5204 today. The percent positive continues to climb and is now 38.2%.
The Governor indicates that the state is not testing at the level we want to, and we are hampered mostly by a lack of people to conduct the tests and PPE. He did indicate that the availability of Abbott's new 15-minute test would be a game changer in making more tests available. While it would allow testing at local doctor office and urgent care centers, the workers there would still need PPE, so that issue would need to be addressed. But a 15-minute test would eliminate the lag time in test results, giving a more current picture of the crisis.
Also, the rate of growth in positive test results has increased, after declining over the past 3 days. But it isn't clear if that increase is just normal variation or due to the limited testing of symptomatic people.
NJ needs to find away to increase the testing rate by at least 50% to about 7500 per day.
I think those collecting test samples need N95 masks and face shields, since the test requires sticking a swab up the subject's nose and down their throat, which could cause them to cough, sneeze, or otherwise aspirate the virus.Sterilization of masks has been now been approved and is really a no-brainer.
Our throw away culture has created the ppe shortage.
Sterilization of masks has been now been approved and is really a no-brainer.
Our throw away culture has created the ppe shortage.
In theory, the death rate should continue going up for awhile longer, based on it being a lagging indicator vs. cases, which are still going up and are likely to keep going up for awhile, given growing outbreaks outside of NY/NJ. Need to wait to see the end of the day data and we'd really need to see the deaths per day data level off and/or decline for many days before being confident that the trend is real. However, if we see a real trend in deaths, there should be far less "uncertainty" about the data vs. positive cases, which we know are a strong function of tests conducted, as deaths attributed to COVID-19 should be pretty damn obvious.According to worldOmeter
525 deaths in US on 3/28
363 deaths in US on 3/29
288 deaths in US so far today 3/30 We won’t know the final number for 5 hours.
Is this a trend? Could it be that the use of hydrochloriquine is helping with the number of deaths?
Something to watch.