ADVERTISEMENT

OT: New York Mets 2024-2025 Off Season Thread

Padre fan here.

I don’t mean to be that guy to rain on the parade, but I think this one might haunt the Mets.

This dude is a DH, nothing more, nothing less. $700 mill is crazy. Yanks dodged a bullet IMO.
Kind of a bad year to call someone a DH, no more no less, given the MVP. The guy rakes. There’s a reason the losers offered $760mm and that multiple other teams were on him.
 
As fans, we should care about a player's salary only in the context of opportunity cost. That is, if you pay this guy you can't pay that other guy whom you might rather have. That is clearly true in salary capped sports, where overpaying a player is a legitimate fan concern. In baseball, which is not capped, it just comes down to the owner's ability and willingness to spend. Cohen's ability to spend is for practical purposes unlimited. His willingness? We shall see.
 
As fans, we should care about a player's salary only in the context of opportunity cost. That is, if you pay this guy you can't pay that other guy whom you might rather have. That is clearly true in salary capped sports, where overpaying a player is a legitimate fan concern. In baseball, which is not capped, it just comes down to the owner's ability and willingness to spend. Cohen's ability to spend is for practical purposes unlimited. His willingness? We shall see.
We just did.
 
Boy, the haters come out of the woodwork. They would have been singing a different tune if Soto had signed with their team.


Player Dont Be Hatin GIF by Jamie Kennedy
 
Great player...

Mets sign him and now he will become Bobby Bonilla Part Deux
Mets signed Lindor to a 10 year 341mm deal. He's produced 21.5 WAR in the first four years as a Met, each year more WAR than the last. Two silver slugger awards, 3 years in the top ten for MVP including runner up last year to Ohtani. #notBonilla
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift
Mets signed Lindor to a 10 year 341mm deal. He's produced 21.5 WAR in the first four years as a Met, each year more WAR than the last. Two silver slugger awards, 3 years in the top ten for MVP including runner up last year to Ohtani. #notBonilla
Thats Lindor not Soto
 
Kind of a bad year to call someone a DH, no more no less, given the MVP. The guy rakes. There’s a reason the losers offered $760mm and that multiple other teams were on him.
He hits well, and has a solid eye. He will hit in certain spots and the stats will always be there.

He doesn’t field well, his gold glove with the Padres was comical. Dude was our worst defensive OFer.

Also plenty of rumors/reports he was late to team bus, killed chemistry, was a “me” guy.

Maybe that changes now that he got paid. Yanks can take that money and piece together a better team IMO.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Knight Shift
Ok, Celebration is over, what’s next?

Buehler, Manaea
Alonso
Inglesias
Bullpen

Trades?
 
All that '"tradition", 27 rings and playing with Mr. May 2.0 meant nothing. Maybe it was how he saw the fanbase treat Judge? 🥸
Mets fan base no better. NY=NY. Clearly the tradition, relationships, etc. meant nothing because when you are talking about that kind of money the difference was basically a rounding error.
 
Way too much money invested in one player for me. And he can’t pitch or field. I would have rather strategically deployed the funds in multiple assets using FA and potential trades. I wonder what a candid Stearns things about this deal since this seems like a big d... swing by Cohen. I killed the Yankees for years during the George Steinbrenner era for such prolific spending and my views on what type of club I prefer to root for has not changed. Cohen better keep spending because expectations have just increased significantly and that team still has holes particularly on the pitching staff.
 
So glad my Bombers didnt sign him. Been hoping they weren't going to since WS. Hands down the worst outfielder in MLB. Outside of his last groundout he hustles as well as Gleybar Torres. Forget his effort in OF. This dude cares about 3 things...money, himself & hitting
 
I'm thrilled. Definitely an overpay, but it's not my money and if he produces for a decade, that's all I care about. I think part of this is Steve Cohen's push for the casino and development around Citi Field.... now they have their face.

As a die hard Mets/Jets fan, my only question is which body part tears in his first game with the Mets?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ldwnmas
Boy, the haters come out of the woodwork. They would have been singing a different tune if Soto had signed with their team.


Player Dont Be Hatin GIF by Jamie Kennedy
I remember a time not too long ago when Met fans would say the Yanks suck because they buy their championships. I guess until the Mets win a championship they aren’t really hypocrites.
 
I remember a time not too long ago when Met fans would say the Yanks suck because they buy their championships. I guess until the Mets win a championship they aren’t really hypocrites.


Show Me The Money GIF


Now that the Mets are in that neighborhood, it's not a bad thing.

🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Knight Shift
He was a better hitter for the Yanks than the Friars, but still a DH in my mind.

He couldn’t hit Oppo for 2/3rds of the year for us.

Even with that bat, every time a ball would go his way I would cringe. And him running the bases looks like a giraffe that hasn’t found his legs yet.

Then of course there was always those key at bats where you want him to swing and he goes down looking on a pitch because he trusts his eye so much.

Would love to have him back in SD, but 15-765? Sheeesh.
702768f6923db2536fe74a1d6a04adede4692d42b480af2ccdd8d5941e8f9e85_1.jpg
 
. . . Dude was our worst defensive OFer.

. . . .
Yes, at least the Yankees still have Judge out there. While Judge did drop that can of corn to center field in the fifth inning of game 5 and then wander his way toward Teoscar Hernandez's game-tying double, he'll be a wiser 33 years old next year and will fix all of that. I'm sure Soto will make similar adjustments in 2032, his age 33 year.
 
Last edited:
I'm thrilled. Definitely an overpay, but it's not my money and if he produces for a decade, that's all I care about. I think part of this is Steve Cohen's push for the casino and development around Citi Field.... now they have their face.

As a die hard Mets/Jets fan, my only question is which body part tears in his first game with the Mets?
We’ll see.

As for that, I think we already had someone who fits the part.
 
Throw in the fact Citi Field with a Casino, hotel and other one stop entertainment in the proposed complex will be a must see destination for tourism, or of course you could checkout THE Bronx.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT