The team’s original $325 million offer included deferred money that would have lowered the total value of the contract, but a source said Cohen removed that aspect while dining with Lindor. In doing so, Cohen made the $325 million offer worth more in present-day money than Fernando Tatis’ $340 million contract and Mookie Betts’ $365 million deal. Although the deal wouldn’t technically make Lindor the highest-paid shortstop in Major League history, for all intents and purposes, it would.
For that reason, sources described Cohen as upset and baffled as the hours ticked down to Lindor’s self-imposed deadline. He and other Mets officials expected Lindor to meet them at $325 million, after they made an offer earlier in spring of around $300 million. Although the Mets consider Lindor a perfect fit for them at shortstop both on and off the field, they believe $325 million already exceeds their internal projections of his future performance. As such, they do not intend to increase their offer, nor meet Lindor in the middle.