Reasonable center-left takes, so much appreciated. So allow me to react from a center-right view. Average people only really compare themselves to themselves. Those with an agenda, such as to make people feel like victims, point out what others are getting. The 2017 tax cuts helped people at the lower end more than the higher end. I believe it was 5+% after tax. So wages were going up, unemployment was going down, and they got to keep more of what they made. Unfortunately, much of the healthcare costs are the result of the ACA. So in the later 44 years, things were improving in terms of employment and wage growth, but they were being eaten up by higher healthcare costs from company plans having to be compliant with ACA, the result being higher out of pocket costs and less competition (all the hospital systems buying each other up, like RWJ Barnabas). The combination of wage growth and tax cuts under 45 got people back to even and then in the black again. My hope with any of these discussions is not to change anyone's point of view, but to show that there are equally compelling facts from the opposite perspective.